Dear sisters and brothers,
1. Solidarity with Palestine
Let me begin by expressing my heartfelt regret that we could not put our plan into practice to follow the invitation of our Palestinian brothers and sisters to meet in the town of Bethlehem. After the escalation of the situation in the region through the US-Israeli attack on Iran beginning on 28 February and the following exchanges with our local hosts, the painful decision had to be made to return to our original plan of holding the meeting online. Since we cannot show our solidarity by our physical presence now, all the more I want to express my deep sympathy with those in Palestine who continue to experience the injustice of occupation and dramatically increased violence by Israeli settlers not seeking reconciliation but violently attacking Palestinian locals and taking their land without any effective protection by the Israeli authorities. We are also continuously praying for the people in Gaza who are still going through a humanitarian catastrophe and have so far in vain waited for the promised reconstruction without both the regime of Hamas and the ongoing military threat by the Israeli army. While the world has shifted its attention to other conflict or war sites the Palestinian people continues to need our support in their struggle for sovereignty and a state in which they can decide themselves about their future and can live along with Israelis in mutual recognition of each one’s right to live in this land according to international law.
We see with great worries how international law has increasingly come under pressure – not only in the Middle East but also in other regions of the world whether through the continuing immoral Russian invasion in Ukraine or the multiple violations of international law and the systematic subversion of multilateralism by the present US administration.
2. Common ecumenical witness against the misuse of Christian religion
This is a time in which the common ecumenical witness to the world for the God-given dignity of every human being and the duty of governments to respect this dignity in their own countries and between countries are more important than ever before.
The most urgent reason for such witness is the unscrupulous misuse of Christian religion to legitimize political actions that are in deep contradiction to fundamental biblically-based orientations. While in recent history we have known Islamist regimes for a quite a while, which have instrumentalized the religion of Islam for their fundamentalist political purposes, the instrumentalization of the Christian religion for political purposes that are in deep contradiction to its fundamental orientations has reached a new level. Currently we see how the leadership of both old superpowers Russia and United States scandalously misuse Christianity to get support for their political agenda.
Calling the invasion of a neighbouring country a “Holy war” – as it was the case in a document entitled “The Present and Future of the Russian World” issued on 28 March 2024, by the World Council of Russian Peoples, is such misuse. There is no Holy war. War is always against the will of God. Even when the use of violence is necessary to protect people from being murdered, it can never be blessed but only seen as an unfortunate choice between two evils.
A similar misuse of Christian religion can be seen in the U.S., where the Bible and Christian rhetoric are instrumentalized for legitimizing policies originating from completely different ideological origins. Chasing immigrants, closing development agencies that had saved many peoples’ lives and humiliating people by calling them “animals” but also promoting a roll back to fossil energies, which will leave a huge bill to coming generations, and sabotaging a multilateral order wherever possible, are in obvious tension with the message of the gospel. In addition, portraying a political leader in social media posts with AI generated pictures as a God-sent messiah can only be called blasphemy.
Unmasking these forms of disguise by some of the most powerful political leaders on this globe is not only a matter of advocacy for all those especially vulnerable who are victims of the policies connected with it. It is also a necessity for mission and evangelism. Who will believe us all our words on the beauty of Christian faith, on selfless love, on empathy, on humility, on peace-making as forms of witness to our Lord Jesus Christ, if we as churches do not address with clear words these misuses of our religion, which pull the name of Christ into the dirt?!
The misuse of religion was also a theme when the general secretary, the vice-moderators and I visited Pope Leo XIV on 28 February. You might recognize the date. It was the morning after the beginning of the attacks on Iran. On the way to our meeting in the papal library, we were all checking the latest news about what had happened in the night. We talked to the pope about the events and about our calling as churches in this moment of history. Beyond all condemnation of the oppressive Iranian regime, we affirmed that massive bombing with all escalation risks was not the way to achieve a peaceful coexistence in the future. The strong level of agreement we felt, was an experience of the ecumenism of the heart that our unity document of the WCC 11th Assembly in Karlsruhe 2022 puts in the centre of our ecumenical vision.
Meanwhile in his repeated calls for peace, Pope Leo does not only speak for the Roman Catholic Church but for all Christians who orient their thinking and action around Christ. Speaking in Cameroon, the Pope criticized leaders who “turn a blind eye to the fact that billions of dollars are spent on killing and devastation, yet the resources needed for healing, education and restoration are nowhere to be found”. And he also emphasized that “the masters of war pretend not to know that it takes only a moment to destroy, yet often a lifetime is not enough to rebuild.”
As Christians we are united in our call for a peace that does not primarily rely on military might. We might have different opinions amongst ourselves about the role that military action can play as an emergency measure to protect human lives. But I believe we all agree that military violence can never be blessed or celebrated. And we also agree that the huge and even increasing amounts of financial resources used to buy arms while many people die every day because there are not enough resources for development and humanitarian aid are a moral scandal.
3. The challenge of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
It is a good ecumenical sign that as the WCC we are not only experiencing much agreement with Pope Leo on issues of peace but also on an issue, which will be of crucial importance for the future of humanity. On 13-14 April, the WCC held a symposium with partners at the Bread for the World building in Berlin, bringing together AI experts and church leaders from around the world to discuss the ethical dimensions of AI and the responsibility of the churches. WCC had previously issued several statements by the executive committee and the central committee that focused on the challenge of AI. At the invitation of WCC a group of people had already gathered in September 2021 in the same building for the first global ecumenical meeting, which focused specifically on the impacts of digital transformation on justice, the public sphere, and our vision for the future. Since then, the opportunities and challenges identified at that time have only intensified, and the need for collective action has become even more urgent.
Probably never before in history have we witnessed such a rapid transformation in such a short time. The French sociologist Emile Durkheim has used the term “anomie” when he described the situation at the end of the 19th century after a century of rapid transformation through an industrial revolution that humankind had never seen before. “Anomie” means a “lack of rules”. Society, said Durkheim, had experienced a deep transformation, so rapid, that the rules for dealing with it responsibly did not keep up with the rapidity of this transformation.
I am convinced that Durkheim’s diagnosis fits our situation today even much more drastically. We live in an age of anomie to an extent never seen before. With digitalization and AI as its most revolutionary consequence, we are experiencing a fundamental societal transformation not in the course of a century but in the course of a decade. We have seen the steep rise of data corporations, which have taken on the character of monopolies. Through their governance of algorithms, they have developed a tremendous amount of power not only over the communication patterns of a large part of humanity but also about the knowledge which drives the different sectors of economy and society. Their close ties to political power result in an amount of power in the hands of a few people which we have probably never seen in history before, and which represent a growing threat to democracy.
How can we respond to these threats? How can we meet the challenges that are connected with this situation? How can we be agents rather than objects of this development? How can we shape the development of AI responsibly by using its life-affirming potential and limiting the risks connected with it?
And most importantly, where are the institutions which can help us finding answers to the moral and ethical question that the development of AI poses? Or to say it with the terminology of Emile Durkheim: how can we overcome anomie by finding the appropriate rules for a responsible use of AI?
I firmly believe that the churches will have to play a decisive role in this endeavour. The global challenge we face can only be met by institutions with a global horizon.
Several billion inhabitants of this earth are members of churches and religious communities. There is probably no other group of people who would have a similar potential to encourage the global response to AI that we so urgently need. The churches are rooted locally everywhere in the world, from the great metropoles in the urban areas to the smallest villages in the rainforest, and at the same time they are united in a global horizon based on our common faith in God the creator of heaven and earth, in Christ the personified love of God and in the Holy Spirit who leads people with various different national, cultural and social backgrounds together.
Building on these spiritual resources to become a driving force for a morally sound global transformation is not primarily a political or social task. It is, above all, a response to the call by Jesus himself to be salt of the earth and light of the world.
I therefore all the more welcome the recent encyclical of Pope Leo XIV on the topic of AI, published on 25 May under the title “Magnifica Humanitas” (Latin for “The Magnificent Humanity”). The pope calls for establishing effective mechanisms to protect freedom and human dignity against data corporations whose monopoly power is now virtually uncontrollable. When it comes to artificial intelligence, what is at stake, is how we understand humanity. The pope affirms that AI can imitate and simulate the person, but it does not possess a moral conscience, empathy, or affective, relational or spiritual capabilities. Very much in tune with WCC’s insights Pope Leo claims that the guiding principle must not solely be profit but the dignity of every person and the common good of all people.
Along the same lines as the WCC the pope emphasizes the human obligation of responsibility and accountability at every stage of the development process, focusing on adequate AI policies and legal frameworks, independent oversight, and user education. The encyclical’s thorough anthropological reflection shows that the churches, with their rich treasure of have something important to say here. Pope Leo is now giving a strong impulse to this discussion, which will hopefully have as great an impact on the global public as Pope Francis’s encyclical Laudato Si’ had on the issue of ecology.
At the Berlin conference I summarized the guidance, which an ecumenical perspective on AI can give, in 10 theses:
- Artificial Intelligence is neither to be simply condemned nor to be enthusiastically embraced. There are clear risks in the use of AI. Yet there is also a great potential, for example in the medical field, to alleviate suffering and promote human and ecological development.
- The rapid development of these new technological instruments has not been accompanied by an equally rapid development of the rules necessary to deal with it responsibly (“anomie”). We urgently need a vivid discussion on these rules in global civil society. This discussion must involve knowledgeable experts who can provide the professional competence needed, representatives of churches and religious communities who can contribute substantial inputs on moral guidance, and political decision-makers, who can share the problems and challenges in forming the political will and organizing political majorities for a responsible use of AI globally. The prerequisite of this discussion is full transparency of actors in the further development of AI and its application.
- The churches as locally rooted communities with moral reflection and a global horizon being part of their very DNA are called to stand in the first row when such global civil society discussion process is to be organized. What needs to be developed is a public theology of AI.
- The moral guidance, which the churches can introduce in the ethical discussion process on AI, is based on their understanding of the human being as we see it in the biblical narrative. Theological anthropology is based on Jesus Christ as the human being in which God’s will for humanity has been shown.
- In Jesus Christ we see someone, who shows as a vulnerable human being whose earthly human existence ends with a cry of despair on the cross. Jesus’ vulnerability is in tension with the ideal of human perfection through technology as, for example, transhumanism promotes it. It puts us at the side of those especially vulnerable amongst us today.
- The purpose of human life is love. The double commandment of love provides the central guidance for responsibly dealing with the potential of AI. AI is therefore a blessing when it helps alleviating human suffering or the suffering of the earth. It can become a danger, when it promotes division, instigates hate or deepens the asymmetries of power in society.
- Human beings can love. Machines cannot love. Any confusion in this distinction must be avoided.
- Who profits from AI? AI involves major questions of justice. Our Christian understanding of justice is based on the “preferential option for the poor” which can be identified in all major traditions of the Bible.
- Responsibility is the central characteristic of human handling of AI. It is an indispensable dimension of our relationship to God. Machines cannot be responsible. The use of AI must always be based on human responsibility and decisions that arise from such responsibility.
- Human responsibility is nurtured by hope. New technological developments do not represent the path to doom but provide the potential for a life in dignity for every human being and human care for non-human creation. Hope leads to action towards these goals.
4. Common witness in the spirit of Pentecost
Pentecost is God’s great miracle of communication. The story of Pentecost tells of how very different people come together. They speak different languages, just as we do today in a figurative sense. Yet everyone hears the disciples telling of God’s great deeds. For me, that is exactly what the World Council of Churches is striving for, and what we in our various forms in our churches are also striving for together: that we talk to one another, that we listen to one another, and that we understand one another, despite our different backgrounds. And when I look at the state of the world, what we need most right now are people who are simply willing to listen. And to tolerate what is very different, and perhaps even realize that there is something to be learned from it.
The Pentecost story is, however, not just about a kind of harmonious neutrality. It speaks of how they all heard about the great deeds of God. The sermon has a message. We as Christians are not simply neutral moderators in a world of many voices. Rather, we are called to proclaim to the world God’s redeeming love and forgiveness, God’s justice, God’s preferential option for the poor, Christ’s call for overcoming of violence and the uniting power of the Holy Spirit. This is what carries the promise of understanding beyond our different languages.
I am praying for such Pentecostal spirit in this executive committee meeting and in all the work we will do when the meeting is over – in the WCC and in our home churches. May God accompany us with God’s blessings!
Bishop Dr Heinrich Bedford-Strohm
Moderator of the central committee
World Council of Churches